UC Irvine-led study finds relationship between nursing home staffing types and care quality
Optimal health outcomes require insight into correlation between disciplines, residents’ needs
July 18, 2024
“Understanding the interdependence between disciplines is crucial for developing effective staffing regulations and ultimately improving the quality of care in nursing homes,” says first author Dana Mukamel, PhD.
Photo courtesy of UC Irvine.
Irvine, Calif. — As nursing homes constantly strive to balance staffing decisions and optimal health outcomes for residents, a new study led by the University of California, Irvine reveals the complex relationship between different staff disciplines and quality of care.
Recently published online in the Journal of the American Medical Directors Association, the study found opposite effects between registered nurses (RNs), licensed practical nurses (LPNs) and certified nursing assistants (CNAs) on various quality measures, ranging from antipsychotic medication usage to treating pressure sores.
“These novel results provide a more complex picture of the influence of staffing types on quality measures,” said first author Dana Mukamel, PhD, a Distinguished Professor of medicine at the UCI School of Medicine. “The intricate relationship between nursing disciplines and resident care requires a nuanced approach to policies that go beyond simple headcounts. Hiring decisions, including ones about staffing mix, should be tailored to meet the needs of individual residents.”
The team constructed separate models for six distinct quality measures associated with quality, using RNs, LPNs and CNAs as key independent variables. Previously unavailable payroll information from nursing homes across the country was leveraged to provide a comprehensive view of staffing patterns, including weekends and holidays. The study’s novel insights are credited to the use of the well-established economics technique, Two Stage Least Squares, which has not been used in most previous nursing home staffing studies in this field.
Key findings indicate that higher numbers of RNs led to more frequent use of antipsychotic drugs, fewer hospitalizations and emergency room visits, and better care for pressure sores. Increased levels of CNAs, however, resulted in a decrease in antipsychotic drug use, improvements in long-stay activities of daily living and short-stay functioning, but also an increase in hospitalizations. The team also found that RN and CNA staffing levels were associated with better quality much more often than LPNs.
“These outcomes suggest that RNs and CNAs have a different focus in their roles," Mukamel said. "CNAs are often closer to residents. This enables them to develop insights into residents’ routines and offer behavioral modifications to mitigate symptoms, while RNs might focus on communicating behavioral issues to prescribing providers and developing overall care plans. The difference in pressure sore improvement reflects the complexity of treatment, which requires close guidance and supervision from RNs.
“Understanding the interdependence between disciplines is crucial for developing effective staffing regulations and ultimately improving the quality of care in nursing homes.”
Study team members also include Dr. Debra Saliba, UCLA Anna & Harry Borun Professor of Medicine; R. Tamara Konetzka, the Louis Block Professor of Public Health Sciences and professor of medicine at the University of Chicago; and Heather Ladd, a senior statistician with the UC Irvine School of Medicine's Department of Medicine.
This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health's National Institute on Aging under award number R01AG066742.
Related stories
About UCI Health
UCI Health, one of California’s largest academic health systems, is the clinical enterprise of the University of California, Irvine. The system comprises its main campus UCI Medical Center, a 459-bed, acute care hospital in in Orange, Calif., four hospitals and affiliated physicians of the UCI Health Community Network in Orange and Los Angeles counties and ambulatory care centers across the region. Recognized as a Top Hospital by The Leapfrog Group, UCI Medical Center provides tertiary and quaternary care and is home to Orange County’s only National Cancer Institute-designated comprehensive cancer center, high-risk perinatal/neonatal program and American College of Surgeons-verified Level I adult and Level II pediatric trauma center, gold level 1 geriatric emergency department and regional burn center. UCI Health serves a region of nearly 4 million people in Orange County, western Riverside County and southeast Los Angeles County. Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn and Twitter.
About UCI Health — Irvine
UCI Health — Irvine, a new medical complex under construction at the north end of the UC Irvine campus, will bring unparalleled expertise and the finest evidence-based care that only an academic health system can offer to the communities of coastal and south Orange County. As part of UCI Health — which includes the flagship UCI Medical Center in Orange, Orange County’s only National Cancer Institute-designated comprehensive cancer center and multiple outpatient care locations — the new 1.2 million-square-foot campus will offer key clinical programs in oncology, digestive health, neurology, neurosurgery, orthopedics and spine surgery. The nation’s first all-electric, carbon-neutral medical center, UCI Health — Irvine is home to The Joe C. Wen & Family UCI Health Center for Advanced Care, a five-story, 168,000-square-foot medical facility offering the full range of multidisciplinary specialty care for children and adults under a single roof, urgent care services, the Center for Children’s Health and the UCI Health Center for Autism & Neurodevelopmental Disorders. The Chao Family Comprehensive Cancer Center and Ambulatory Care building, a 225,000-square-foot facility, opened July 16. Coming in 2025: a seven-story, 350,000-square-foot, acute care hospital and 24-hour emergency department.
